The Birth of The Lincoln Deception

After many years as a trial and appellate lawyer, David O. Stewart became a bestselling writer of history and historical fiction. His histories have explored the writing of the Constitution, the gifts of James Madison, the outrageous western expedition and treason trial of the mysterious Aaron Burr, and the impeachment trial of President Andrew Johnson. Today, David shares the background for his historical novel The Lincoln Deception.

The Birth of The Lincoln Deception ~~ by David O. Stewart

The dusty volume, a biography of John Bingham, was stiff when I opened it in the main reading room of the Library of Congress.  I suspected that no one had looked at it since it was printed, on cheap paper, in 1989.

I trudged through each page, looking for something that would illuminate the historical narrative I was researching about the impeachment trial of Andrew Johnson.  Bingham, from Ohio, should be remembered far more than he is.  Not only had he led Johnson’s impeachers.  He also wrote the Fourteenth Amendment’s guarantees of due process and equal protection, and prosecuted eight people accused of conspiring with John Wilkes Booth to assassinate Abraham Lincoln.

A single paragraph in that neglected book drove me to historical fiction. The author reported an account of Bingham’s death in 1900.  Bingham, the story went, told the doctor attending him that during the conspiracy trial he learned a terrible secret about Lincoln’s assassination. If revealed, the dying man added, the secret could have destroyed the republic. He told only War Secretary Edwin Stanton, who took the secret to his grave. Now, Bingham added, the secret would die with him.  Which it did.

For months, I couldn’t get that account out of my head. After I had written the impeachment book and another work of history, I decided to investigate Bingham’s secret. The Booth conspiracy, I was reminded, aimed to kill not only the president, but also Vice President Johnson, Secretary of State William Seward, General Ulysses Grant and Secretary of War Stanton. It was not just an assassination; it was an attempted coup d’etat. 

Conspiracy theorists have gummed over the Lincoln tragedy for more than a century. They have blamed Jefferson Davis, Pope Pius IX, and even Stanton. Their theories have ranged from unpersuasive to ridiculous. I concluded that Bingham had kept his secret well. I could not write a work of history about it.

Still, the tale festered in my mind. So I decided to make up Bingham’s secret, which meant I would be writing fiction.  My version of Bingham’s secret had to be plausible, consistent with known facts. As my saying goes for historical fiction, you can make up a lot, but Lincoln has to be tall.  One protagonist, I decided, would be the doctor at Bingham’s deathbed; I drew another from local history in eastern Ohio.

Thus was born The Lincoln Deception, which was reissued recently, to be followed by two successor titles through the year.

For me, veering over the last ten years between historical fiction and narrative history, I believe the two genres enrich each other.  Writing narrative history makes me insist that the facts in my novels accord with what we know about that time and place and people. (Lincoln is tall!)  Indeed, when mastering historical facts, the writer asks the same questions a novelist needs to apply to her characters.

Why did a person make a statement or take an action? Are accounts of those words or actions plausible? Is the person reporting the incident reliable? What motives drove that person to record or relate those facts? (In novels, cue the unreliable narrator!) I have to know as much as I can about the foreign land of the past in order to recreate it for readers.

Writing fiction, in turn, opens my historical writing to the world beyond the cold records. Even with immense public figures like Abraham Lincoln or George Washington, the facts we don’t know dwarf what we know. Writing fiction makes me ask more questions about the historical characters I write about.

What happened when the person was off-stage? What did she think or say? Did she grieve or laugh or wonder? Why don’t we know more about an episode – were key figures trying to cover something up? Were they ashamed of something? Silences in the record can tell so much.

To take the process full circle, those same questions apply to every character in a historical novel:  those who are imagined (like the two amateur investigators in my novels) and those borrowed from history.

I am far from unique in writing both historical fiction and narrative histories. Distinguished genre-straddlers include Simon Sebag Montefiore, Allison Weir, and Shelby Foote. And many others.  Maybe there’s something to it.

Many thanks, David. Imagine my surprise to discover that the man behind The Lincoln Deception was John Bingham, who shares the name of both my father and my grandfather. Perhaps there’s more to the legacy of this story?

The Lincoln Deception by David O. Stewart ~~ In 1900, John Bingham lies dying in Cadiz, Ohio. He tells his doctor, Jamie Fraser, that he learned a terrible secret thirty-five years before when he prosecuted John Wilkes Booth’s co-conspirators. That secret of the Lincoln assassination, he confides, could destroy the republic, but will die with him.

Fraser, a 39-year-old widower who is weary of small-town doctoring, becomes obsessed with Bingham’s secret. Fate throws him together with the voluble Speed Cook, the last black man to play in the big leagues and aspiring newspaper publisher. Together they puzzle over the fragmentary evidence of the Booth conspiracy and set out to learn more. Their trail takes them to Booth’s nephew (a star actor himself) and the man’s beautiful business manager (who captures Fraser’s heart), and leads to the nation’s leading cotton tycoon, a man with murky connections to the Sons of Liberty, a Northern pro-Confederacy group from the 1860s.

Fraser and Cook face immense risks — a mugging on an Indiana riverside, a race riot in New York City, and a terrifying trap atop the new Williamsburg Bridge. Confounding their pursuers with resourcefulness and courage, they reach a Washington, DC showdown with the shadowy tycoon and the senior surviving general of the Confederate Army and the appalling truth of Mr. Bingham’s secret.

David O. Stewart’s first historical mystery, The Lincoln Deception, was reissued on April 14.  A sequel, The Paris Deception, will reissue on June 28, and a third book in the Fraser/Cook series will reissue in October (The Babe Ruth Deception).  In February 2021, Dutton will release his nonfiction book, George Washington: The Political Rise of America’s Founding Father.

DON’T MISS OTHER POSTS ON READING & WRITING HISTORICAL FICTION.  FOLLOW A WRITER OF HISTORY (using the widget on the left sidebar)

M.K. Tod writes historical fiction. Her latest novel, TIME AND REGRET was published by Lake Union. Mary’s other novels, LIES TOLD IN SILENCE and UNRAVELLED are available from Amazon, NookKoboGoogle Play and iTunes. She can be contacted on Facebook, Twitter and Goodreads or on her website www.mktod.com.

Share this post

About the Author

Meet M.K.Tod

Meet M.K.Tod

The historical fiction author behind A Writer of History...

All Categories

Subscribe to the Blog

Receive the latest posts on writing and reading historical fiction via email.

Join 2,162 other subscribers

10 Responses

  1. The secret held by Bingham was that all judges witnesses and politicians involved in the assassination of Lincoln were related to British royalty and that John Wilkes booth was framed as the assailant and proved in court .

      1. My theses is generational crime, that which those in power have to do to retain their power and wealth.
        In order to inherit a castle the previous generations had to ensure your occupancy as did their parents before them and as they would for the next generation and so forth.
        If the names of those Royals doing the crimes were known the monarchy would be destroyed as would its future. Royalty was related to every President.
        Subsequently that let’s say a republic would be destroyed.
        So said Bingham to his doctor.
        In order to hide the royal name and associated families. Other assailants of crimes needed to be found and proven to be the guilty parties.
        All of the judges, politicians and witnesses of the conspirators trial of the assassination of Abraham Lincoln were related to Royalty.
        I have the details of those relationships.
        The same families went on to kill James Garfield who also advocated rights for let’s say those of servitude races.

      2. The real killer of Abraham Lincoln was 20 year old Emily peck niece of Elizabeth cady Stanton

        1. The confederate side of the Todd family were in my research very involved with Lincoln’s assassination there were six branches of the Todd family evolving from the dundee area of Scotland and 3 of those branches at least were involved in America. Mary Todd Lincoln’s branch was an Irish branch. Another branch of the Todd’s moved down to the pontefract area of England as did the Bingham family and indeed the Washington family before diverging to the south and west of England.
          The second American branch of the Todd family in America were interrelated to the family of Frances Adeline Seward the wife of the claimed attack victim of William H Seward on the same day of the assassination. The Sewards were related to Elizabeth cady Stanton who as did the Binghams occupied the house of Adeline Sewards father.

  2. Ask me how the falsely claimed death of John Wilkes booth is connected to the killer of James Garfield , John f Kennedy and Princess Diana of wales.

  3. Bingham trained in law in Cadiz Ohio with secretary of war edwin Stanton. Stanton also trained in law in Ohio with the son in law of Cicero Hamlin the uncle of Hannibal Hamlin the would be vice president to Abraham Lincoln but for a late change. Hannibal Hamlin as a teenager wanted to be an actor but was deterred by his father to train in law. Hannibal Hamlin as a teenager trained as an actor with the family of John Wilkes Booth. Another Hamlin owned the land on which Laura Keene purchased a house in acushnet Mass. 3 weeks before the assassination her neighbours were the family of the future presidents Roosevelt.

  4. The binghams were also intermarried with Cassius Marcellus clay (the ancestor of Mohammed Ali) Abraham Lincoln’s minister to Russia as was theodopolus Lyle Dickey a famous politician who was a boyhood friend of Abraham Lincoln with whose father Lincoln learned how to play chess ( Lincoln was a poor chess player). Theo Lyle Dickey lost his friendship with Abraham Lincoln over the issue of slavery and the rights of each state to decide for themselves.
    Lincoln learned to suggest that the choice of slavery might be given to each state short term however the emancipation proclamation did not give that option. The related famous Henry clay two years before his death also wrote that the choice of slavery should be given to individual states.

Leave a Reply