• About Me
  • About this blog
  • My Writing
    • Lies Told in Silence
    • Unravelled
  • One Writer’s Voice

A Writer of History

~ thoughts on writing & reading historical fiction

A Writer of History

Monthly Archives: September 2012

HNS London 2012 – an update

30 Sunday Sep 2012

Posted by awriterofhistory in Historical Fiction Survey

≈ 23 Comments

Tags

Emma Darwin, Harry Sidebottom, historical fiction survey, historical novel society, HNS London 2012, Jenny Barden, Justin Neville

The cold struck on Friday, September 21st. “Shit,” I muttered while staring at my laptop but then, in what I like to think of as my ‘cup half full’ approach to life, I told myself it would be over in a week, hardly likely to affect my attendance at the Historical Novel Society conference in London. Might need some cough lozenges and hand sanitizer – the lozenges so I could listen and talk without too much hacking, the hand sanitizer so I wouldn’t infect any fellow writers, members of the publishing industry or historical fiction enthusiasts.

I was, as some of you readers might recall, scheduled to talk about the historical fiction survey at the conference.

The flu struck on Tuesday, September 25th. I spent most of that day and all day Wednesday dozing on and off, eating nothing and, on the advice of Jenny Barden (Conference Coordinator and programme director) and my mother, drinking hot water infused with lemon and honey. To no avail.

On Thursday morning, I admitted defeat. This gal was not going to fly across the Atlantic Thursday night, I could barely think straight or keep anything down let alone pack, get myself to the airport and endure ten or more hours of travel. Jenny was amazing. My fellow panelists, Justin Neville, Emma Darwin and Harry Sidebottom, agreed to look after the session and I returned to bed. This ranks as my biggest disappointment of 2012.

But that’s not the end of the story.

In the tradition of compelling historical fiction, where disaster strikes from unexpected quarters, knights in shining armour ride to the rescue and princesses remain the hidden power, the following unfolded.

  • I sent my speaking notes to Justin but given the feeble state of my brain, did not copy Emma, Harry or Jenny.
  • Saturday morning, Justin was in a car accident on the way to the conference. Very good news – Justin was not hurt.
  • Harry brought an earlier version of my agenda to the breakout session.
  • Emma brought a copy of my survey results.
  • Emma and Harry carried the day – or as Emma said, “we busked it”.

Drama and serendipity – a noteworthy combination. I offer grateful thanks to all involved.

Top Historical Fiction Authors Talk about Branding

28 Friday Sep 2012

Posted by awriterofhistory in Historical Fiction, Connecting Readers & Writers, Top Historical Fiction Authors

≈ 4 Comments

Tags

Sharon Kay Penman, Elizabeth Chadwick, favourite historical fiction authors, CW Gortner, Margaret George, Michelle Moran, Deanna Raybourn, Helen Hollick, Hilary Mantel, author brand, brand represents trust, Susuan Higginbotham, JK Rowling, The Casual Vacancy

As James Patterson said in a quote I used several days ago: “Brands are nothing more than trust.”

I asked each of the top historical fiction authors I interviewed what brand they are trying to create for themselves and I thought it might be interesting to look at their responses collectively.

Do not think of myself as having a brand – Sharon Kay Penman and Hilary Mantel

Personal brand – Helen Hollick, CW Gortner and Deanna Raybourn

Series brand – Helen Hollick

Well-researched historical fiction from a less travelled point of view – Susan Higginbotham

Writer of famous women whose names have been obscured by history – Michelle Moran

Historical accuracy married to vivid story-telling that puts the reader there in the moment – Elizabeth Chadwick

Biographicals – Margaret George (something that evolved rather than a planned brand)

Bringing to life misunderstood or maligned characters or eras – CW Gortner refers to this as a possible future brand

Other than Chadwick, none of the authors mentioned great stories as part of their brand, however, since they are all recognized as great storytellers, I’m going to assume that they each would have added that to their brand statement.

Returning to the notion of trust, when we pick up a Margaret George book we know we’re in for a great fictionalized biography of people like Mary Magdalene or Helen of Troy; Susan Higginbotham will bring us lesser know figures from history like Kate Woodville, sister to Elizabeth or Bess de Montacute who marries Hugh le Despenser;  Michelle Moran gives us stories of Cleopatra’s Daughter and Nefertiti; and, Helen Hollick delivers another exciting story about her pirate, Jesemiah Acorne or another instalment in one of her series about King Arthur or King Harold. We trust them. After all, they’re our favourite authors.

So let’s switch to another favourite author, JK Rowling and her just released adult book, The Casual Vacancy. The Huffington Post offers a round-up of reviews with eight relatively negative and only two positive. Reading them, one has the impression that if Rowling was not already famous, she might not have made it past the agent stage.

And what’s my point? JK Rowling has a brand, a wonderful brand that has served her and her readers well for many years. She has abandoned that brand and broken trust with her readers. The jury is out on whether she will be able to establish a new brand.

Historical Fiction Author Jennifer Niven

24 Monday Sep 2012

Posted by awriterofhistory in Historical Fiction, Writing about WWII, Writing Process

≈ Leave a Comment

Tags

author interviews, Becoming Clementine, Jennifer Niven, The Ice Master, Velva Jean Hart, writing historical fiction

Jennifer Niven is an accomplished writer of both fiction and nonfiction. Her latest novel, Becoming Clementine, launches tomorrow, September 25. Jennifer graciously agreed to be interviewed for A Writer of History and I asked her the same sort of questions I asked the top historical fiction authors.

Why do you write both historical fiction and historical non-fiction?     I have always been drawn to the true story.  I come from a long line of Southern storytellers, and one of our favorite past times was and is telling stories.  Whenever we gather together, whether it’s on the front porch of one of the North Carolina family homesteads or at Lincoln Center in New York City, we inevitably start spinning tales.  Some of them (our equivalent of the Top Ten) get told each time we’re together, even though we’ve all heard them a hundred times before.  The thing these stories have in common is that they’re true.  Truth really is stranger than fiction, and as a writer of both nonfiction and historical fiction, I clearly find inspiration in real people and real events.

Because I consider myself a writer first and foremost, as opposed to a “writer of nonfiction” or “writer of fiction,” I write both historical fiction and historical nonfiction.  I like to think I can write just about anything I put my mind to, which is why I’ve also written a memoir, film scripts, short stories, plays, movies, and television scripts.

Do you have a preference?     I don’t have a preference, but each time I’m coming to the end of a project, I get very wistful about the other genre.  In other words, if I’m writing fiction, I wish I were doing non-fiction (because I wouldn’t have to make up so much of the story on my own and be responsible for so many decisions and details).  And when I’m writing nonfiction, I sometimes long for the freedom of fiction (and the lack of footnotes or endnotes, which I hate, as necessary as they are!).

Is one easier than the other? More successful than the other?     I think both are equally challenging, both in the same ways and in different ones.   I’ve been lucky to have success in historical fiction and historical nonfiction, although the advances and sales for nonfiction are, as a rule, typically greater than for fiction.

How long did it take for your first book, The Ice Master, to be published?     I wrote The Ice Master for Hyperion, selling the idea based on a book proposal.  The proposal went to auction, and I was given sixteen months to research and write the manuscript.  My publisher “crashed” the book, which means they cut their production time in half and hurried the book out just six months after it was edited and completed—a short amount of time in the publishing world! 

As an historical fiction author, what do you think attracts readers to your books?    I tend to write about high-spirited, gutsy, colorful (yet regular) people who survive tough circumstances, loss, and often tragedy, and not only move on, but flourish and triumph in the end.  Almost all the readers I hear from say they are inspired by my characters and their stories, that the characters encourage them to be braver, to feel stronger, that they teach them to carry on.  I hear from cancer survivors, abused women, professional adventurers, teenagers who want to make their mark in the world, housewives, teachers, and so many people who say my books reminded them to pursue dreams they had long since forgotten.

Do you have a particular approach to research and writing?     I keep myself open to the possibilities.  You never know where an idea will lead you.  Many times in my research I’ve set out to study one thing, which has led me to another.  I go off on tangents because there is so much to discover.  You have to let yourself do this, but also know when to rein yourself in.  The same applies to the writing.  I outline before I begin, but I always know that the outline will change—like any good journey, there will be unforeseen detours along the way.  In terms of my daily schedule, I get up every day and work, often seven days a week for 10 or 12 or 16 hours a day.  I hear from people who ask if I only write when I’m inspired, but I work harder than most everyone I know.  It’s a job, but, as far as I’m concerned, it’s the best job in the world.

Have other writers of historical fiction influenced you and, if so, how have they influenced you?     Aside from my mother (who is also a writer), my primary literary influences are Flannery O’Connor, Shirley Jackson, and Harper Lee.  I borrow so many sage and shrewd writing tips from Hemingway.  And Truman Capote’s In Cold Blood (which could arguably be considered historical fiction) is one of my favorite books of all time.  It’s a book I wish I’d written.

What ingredients do you think make for a top historical fiction author? Do you deliberately plan for these ingredients in your writing?     I think you have to possess a love of research—the “research gene,” as my mom calls it.  I could research and research without ever stopping.  Sometimes the book or archival materials or iPad literally has to be removed from my hands so that I will take a break (there are so many fascinating things to learn in this world!).  You need to be able to organize details, facts, and information, while also knowing when to relay the truth and when to dramatize, and how to merge fact and fiction.  So much of it comes down to instinct.

How do you select new stories to tell?     Somehow, the story has a way of selecting me.   I have no shortage of ideas, and only a few of those ever become full-length books.  The stories you’re supposed to tell let you know when it’s time to tell them.  Also, because writing a book is a lengthy and all-consuming process, I need to write a story and characters that I want to spend lots and lots of time with.  I’ve put a number of ideas aside simply because, at the end of the day, I didn’t want to revisit the character (or characters) and setting for months and months at a time.

What advantages do you think come from writing follow on stories as you have done with Velva Jean? Any disadvantages?     Writing a series is a great way to build a fan base of readers who (hopefully) will follow you from one book to another.  And it gives you a chance to build on that readership with each book.  However, the deadlines are tough.  My publisher wanted each Velva Jean novel to come out a year apart, which means I’m editing, editing, editing and promoting and publicizing one book while researching and writing another, and all within about nine months time.  It’s exhausting.

What techniques do you employ to write productively?     I’m lucky in that I’m a very disciplined person.  I have no trouble being productive, because writing is what I love to do most in this world.  I have trouble not writing!  My literary agent calls me one of the most, if not the most, compulsively writing writer he knows.  One rule I follow religiously is something I learned from Hemingway, which is always to leave off in the midst of what you’re working on at the end of your writing day.  This makes it easier to pick up the flow the next morning.  If you come to the end of something on a Monday, it’s that much harder on a Tuesday to go forward, right off the bat, with the same focus and energy.  I also remember something one of my high school English teachers taught me:  “pure economy of word.”  Most of my favorite writers write economically—there’s very little extra fat, if you will.  I write fast and long (my first drafts usually come in around 700 pages), but I have a fondness for dialogue, and an aversion to adverbs and too much description.  I whittle and edit and cut, cut, cut.  So much of writing is editing.  You have to be able to be ruthless with the material.

Do you think of yourself as having a brand? If so, how would you describe it and how do you reinforce it?     It’s so funny you ask this because lately I’ve been trying to figure out just what my brand is.  I’m not a chick lit author or a true crime writer.  I’m not easily classified.  I think my brand is that I’m a writer.  Period.  I write.  I write everything because I love writing.  And I tend to love stories about ordinary people facing extraordinary circumstances.  People with big dreams who aren’t afraid to go after those dreams.  People who are survivors.  I love the underdog, the ordinary, reluctant, unexpected hero.

What do you do to connect with readers?     I’m active on Facebook, Twitter, Pinterest, and Red Room, and I try to keep my website as interesting and dynamic as possible.  I have two amazing interns working with me, and we update our blog posts frequently and also try to include a range of content that will appeal to all types of readers.

What do you know about your readers?     I know that they are hard to pigeonhole as well because they are so diverse.  The readers of my historical fiction are fiercely devoted to my character, Velva Jean Hart (from Velva Jean Learns to Drive, Velva Jean Learns to Fly, and Becoming Clementine), to the point where they weigh in on plotlines and character choices, etc.  I love that they see Velva Jean as a real person and that they’re so invested in her and her stories.  On the other hand, the readers of my nonfiction, for the most part, want to know when I’ll stop “messing around with fiction” and go back to writing true-life adventure history.

What data do you collect about your readers?     I don’t really collect data so much as I pay attention to the things they want to see from me and from my characters.  It’s important to write what you love and what you feel passionate about—to honor the creative muse—but it’s also important to listen to what the reader wants.  After all, as Ralph Waldo Emerson said, “’Tis the good reader that makes the good book.”

What strategies guide your writing career?     I probably should have more of a strategy than I do because my work might be more classifiable and more easily branded.  That said, I write the things I believe in.  Whether I’m working in books or in television, if the idea doesn’t feel organic to me, if I don’t feel it in my bones, then I know I need to put it aside and move on to something else.  I write the things I want to read (or watch).

What would you do differently if you were starting again?     Honestly?  Nothing.  I wrote each book for a very good reason.  Just as I’ve shaped every story, each of those stories—and the experience of researching and writing and promoting and traveling with them, not to mention meeting and hearing from readers—has helped to shape the person I am.

Do you have any advice for writers of historical fiction?     Explore your family history.  There may be something fascinating there that you can incorporate into your story.  Weaving my family’s stories into the books makes Velva Jean’s own story resonate even deeper with me and for me—it makes me feel even more a part of her, of the characters, and of the journey.  I love to sit back and look at the book and see parts of my history in there—things no one else might recognize— and fragments of the people I love.  My other advice is to write what inspires you.  Write what you love.  Read, read, read.  Write, write, write. 

Is there a question you would like to answer that I haven’t asked?     Yes—who has been the most inspiring and influential person in my life?  The answer is my mother, Penelope Niven, who is an author as well.  From a very early age, she told me I could be or do anything.  She taught me not to limit myself.  She taught me to be kind and loving to others.  She passed along the research gene to me.  She taught me the importance of being silly.  She is a positive, gracious person, and imparted that to me as well.  In addition, she shared her love of reading and writing.  Ever since she instilled “writing time” into my childhood routine, I have loved a good story.  While she sat at her grown-up desk, I sat at my little one, crayons in hand, composing fanciful tales about ordinary people who did extraordinary things.  From her, I learned to find the story in everything, to appreciate wonderful characters, and to discover that I could actually realize my dreams of being a detective, an astronaut, an archaeologist, and an actress because a writer is adventurer, explorer, researcher, scholar, and chameleon in one.

Becoming Clementine: It’s summer 1944 and Velva Jean has just become the second woman in history to pilot a bomber across the Atlantic Ocean as a member of the WASP (Women Airforce Service Pilots). After flying the B-17 Flying Fortress into Prestwick, Scotland, she volunteers to copilot a plane carrying special agents to their drop spot over Normandy. Her personal motivation: to find her brother Johnny Clay who is missing in action. But when the plane is shot down over France and only Velva Jean and five agents survive, she is forced to become a fighter; to become a spy; to become Clementine Roux.

Jennifer – many thanks for visiting A Writer of History. I wish you lots of success for Becoming Clementine.

Learning from James Patterson

21 Friday Sep 2012

Posted by awriterofhistory in Writing Process

≈ 4 Comments

Tags

James Patterson, writer's brand

I have a copy of a Harvard Business School case study titled Marketing James Patterson. Published in 2006, the facts and figures are dated but Patterson’s quote concerning brand remains relevant.

Brands are nothing more than trust. I trust I’m going to pick this up and I’m not going to be able to put it down. There will be tension. And pace. And some kind of human identification not just with the heroes but also with the villains. Above all, my brand stands for story. I became successful when I stopped writing sentences and started writing stories. Editors think it’s about style. It’s not. It’s all story.

In May 2012, Patterson’s book 11th Hour was fourth on the New York Times combined print and e-book bestsellers list. I, Michael Bennett, Guilty Wives, Maximum Ride: Nevermore and Zoo are some of his latest releases. With a superb marketing machine and a well-honed formula for working with co-authors, he has at least six more novels coming up and more than 3.4 million Facebook fans.

I wonder what I could learn from studying his model?

Historical Novel Society Conference

18 Tuesday Sep 2012

Posted by awriterofhistory in Historical Fiction, Historical Fiction Survey

≈ 4 Comments

Tags

historical fiction survey, historical novel society, Philippa GRegory, Bernard Cornwell, Diana Gabaldon, Elizabeth Chadwick, CW Gortner, Margaret George, Helen Hollick, HNS London 2012, reader opinions revealed, Emma Darwin, Harry Sidebottom

The days are counting down to the Historical Novel Society conference in London which begins on Friday, September 28. I will be there – excitement enough given the potential to meet all sorts of historical fiction enthusiasts as well as listening to noted and celebrated authors like Emma Darwin, CW Gortner, Diana Gabaldon, Elizabeth Chadwick,  Margaret George, Philippa Gregory, Bernard Cornwell, Harry Sidebottom, Helen Hollick.

Already a shiver is going up and down my spine!

Tension elevates the excitement – tension from two different sources. One source is that I will be on a panel alongside Justin Neville, Harry Sidebottom and Emma Darwin. The topic, Reader Opinions Revealed, is based on the historical fiction survey I conducted last April and have written about in numerous blog posts.

The second source of tension is an opportunity to chat with an editor about my writing, a brief ‘pitch session’ but nonetheless guaranteed to create anxiety as the time approaches.

Advice, crossed fingers and good wishes welcome :)

At Helen Hollick’s Blog Today

17 Monday Sep 2012

Posted by awriterofhistory in Historical Fiction, Historical Fiction Survey, Top Historical Fiction Authors

≈ Leave a Comment

Tags

historical fiction survey, historical novel society, Helen Hollick, HNS London 2012

Helen Hollick – one of the top historical fiction authors who appeared on A Writer of History several weeks ago, is featuring those who are speakers and organizers at the Historical Novel Society Conference on her blog.

I am delighted to be Helen’s guest today with an opportunity to introduce myself and my writing.

The conference promises to be a wonderful event – who can resist being with so many men and women who love historical fiction?

Helen also asked for a list of people I would like to have at my table for Saturday’s banquet – alive, dead, fictional or real. I think my choices would result in amazing conversation :)

Readers from around the world

12 Wednesday Sep 2012

Posted by awriterofhistory in Connecting Readers & Writers

≈ 3 Comments

Tags

A Writer of History, readers are global, technology removes national boundaries, Wordpress stats

I try not to obsess about WordPress stats but today I allowed myself to look at the last 30 days of visitors to A Writer of History.

What amazes me the most is this global world we live in. What could I have to say of interest to someone in Peru? Why do so many folks from India and Netherlands choose to visit? Truly curious and I’m grateful to all of them.

Hit Lit – the final six features

10 Monday Sep 2012

Posted by awriterofhistory in Historical Fiction, Top Historical Fiction Authors, Writing Process

≈ 5 Comments

Tags

favourite historical fiction authors, Gone with the Wind, Hit Lit: Cracking the Code of the Twentieth Century's Biggest Bestsellers, ingredients for best sellers, James W. Hall, Jaws, Peyton Place, The Bridges of Madison County, The Da Vinci Code, The Dead Zone, The Exorcist, The Firm, The Godfather, The Hunt for Red October, To Kill a Mockingbird, Valley of the Dolls, writing techniques

The first post in this series of three explored ‘tricks of the trade’ used by best-selling authors. The second post summarized five of James W. Hall’s twelve features from Hit Lit: Cracking the Code of the Twentieth Century’s Biggest Bestsellers.

This final post outlines Hall’s remaining six features.

Feature #7 – “Bumpkins versus Slickers”

In most bestsellers, there’s a central character who sets off on a journey that takes her from rustic America into turbulent urban landscapes … almost as often, the heroes of bestsellers make an exodus in the opposite direction

Hall and others refer to this as the hero’s journey, a structure that has worked in endless permutations to leverage the ageless clash between city and rural values.

Question: is feature #7 the commoner versus the nobility in historical fiction?

Feature #8 – “God Sells”

Our twelve bestsellers all feature religion in prominent ways, consistently critiquing orthodox religious practice and the dangers of zealotry.

The secular world is juxtaposed against religion that has gone astray and people who claim to adhere to religious values while clearly committing contrary acts. False piety, says Hall. Common sense struggles against religious conviction, science against faith. Langdon of Da Vince Code fame is an example – a man of science clashing with powerful religious leaders.

Question – does religion have such prominence in historical fiction?

Feature #9 – “Americans delight in reenactments of our national myths.”

The rise from humble roots to become rich and powerful. A character struggling against injustice and, finally, triumphing over oppression. And we are also grimly fascinated by the flip side of these stories.

Hall illustrates: Mitch McDeere’s belief in the American Dream (The Firm), Scout Finch’s triumph over racism (To Kill a Mockingbird), Scarlett O’Hara’s example of the virtue of hard work (Gone With the Wind), exposing injustice (The Da Vinci Code), the freedoms of American society clashing against communism (The Hunt for Red October).

Question – is there an equivalent to America’s national myths in historical fiction?

Feature #10 – Rebels, Loners, Misfits and Mavericks

The heroes and heroines … are all rebels, loners, misfits or mavericks. They don’t fit in worth a damn, and that’s one of the reasons we love them so much

Hall explains that the “tension between mavericks and conventionalists operates at the core of the biggest bestsellers”. Heroes of these novels reject conformity and convention. They are strongly individualistic.

Feature #11 – “Fractured Families”

In each of our twelve novels, a member of a broken family finds an ingenious way to transcend his or her crazy stress.

A few pages later Hall states that “twelve of the most successful novels in publishing history and not a traditional, fully functioning family among them, yet all our heroes and heroines find ways to make peace with their extreme losses”.

Perhaps these novels function partly as therapy for readers coping with their own family distress particularly at a time when the traditional family model is changing (some would say has changed).

Feature #12 – yes this is the last one – Sex

In every novel on our list, one key sexual encounter plays a decisive role in the outcome of the plot and in the transformation of the protagonist.

Scarlett’s sexual encounter with Rhett Butler. The false accusation of rape in To Kill a Mockingbird. Unresolved sexual tension between John Smith and his former girlfriend in The Dead Zone. Raunchy sex just before a woman is eaten by a shark in Jaws. Mitch McDeere’s infidelity on a deserted beach in The Firm.

The sexual language may be toned down to broaden the books’ mainstream appeal, but copulation, both violent and extreme, still plays a crucial role in the outcomes of these stories … somewhere in our national consciousness we know that one good roll in the hay can change everything.

 

So … there you have it, the twelve features of bestsellers according to James Hall’s analysis. By the way, he has one final ingredient to add – personal passion. “Without this one last ingredient, a novel might easily contain all the recurring features but still remain a lifeless pile of mush.” There’s still magic involved.

Feedback – what do you think? Do these twelve features resonate in the stories of your favourite historical fiction writers?

More Features of Hit Lit

08 Saturday Sep 2012

Posted by awriterofhistory in Historical Fiction, Top Historical Fiction Authors

≈ 8 Comments

Tags

Gone with the Wind, historical fiction, ingredients for best sellers, James W. Hall, Jaws, Peyton Place, readers' perspectives, The Bridges of Madison County, The Da Vinci Code, The Dead Zone, The Exorcist, The Firm, The Godfather, The Hunt for Red October, To Kill a Mocking Bird, Valley of the Dolls

Two days ago, I wrote about the ‘tricks of the trade’ that make a bestseller so gripping. The analysis comes from James W. Hall’s book on Hit Lit. Ultimately I’d like to consider Hall’s twelve features against some of the top historical fiction authors that readers identified in the survey and these posts are a way for me to clarify ideas in my own mind. Writing helps me think.

Let’s have a look at a few more features:

Feature #2: Raise the controversy of the day

For some hot-button issue to have real wallop, it also must express some larger, deep-seated, and unresolved conflict in the national consciousness.

Hall’s book is peppered with references to the American experience. (This is the time to explain that I am Canadian and hence accustomed to living in the shadow of our great neighbour to the south.) He gives examples of hot-button issues from the twelve bestsellers he’s chosen.

Gone with the Wind – published in 1936 where the hot-button issue was capitalism and its many failures. Remember this is a time when The Depression was a recent experience. In Peyton Place – the hot button was sex. To Kill a Mockingbird – published at a time when race issues were boiling. The Hunt for Red October – cold war paranoia. John Grisham’s The Firm – corporate greed. The Da Vinci Code – religious corruption and conspiracy. “And all of these stories explore some hot-button social issue of their day that is rooted in a long-term national dispute.”

Question: does historical fiction explore today’s hot-button issues or those of long ago?

Feature #3 – “Colossal characters doing magnificent things on a sweeping stage”

Hall asserts that bestsellers pit relatively ordinary people against high stakes situations. Readers are intended to connect to these characters, to be inspired by the aspirations, actions and bravery of everyday heroes like Scout Finch in To Kill a Mockingbird, Mitch McDeere, a small town boy made good in The Firm, Robert Langdon – really just a rumpled professor – in The Da Vinci Code. The characters become colossal because of the fight they take on. David and Goliath come to mind.

Question: are readers fascinated with historical fiction because it allows them to see the everyday person in famous people like Eleanor of Acquitaine or Thomas Cromwell?

Feature #4 – “America as paradise”

America as the new Eden. A land of second chances, fresh beginnings in the virginal wilderness.

Often the novel’s hero is alienated or exiled from their ‘homeland’ and struggles to return. That ‘homeland’ can be the land itself such as in Gone With the Wind and Scarlett’s home Tara, but it can also be a state of innocence, youthful idealism, a time of security, a parent or grandparent.

Feature #5 – “An abundance of facts and information”

Hall explains  that readers want to be informed, to “learn about the larger world”. Whether its the intricacies of a nuclear-powered submarine or the workings of a prestigious law firm or the “double-dealing of showbiz”, readers are fascinated with the facts and figures and the social arrangements and codes of behaviour within these worlds. Readers “read in order to peer inside secret places not open to them otherwise”.

Fact-based fiction has broad appeal because it is simple, hearty fare. No highly refined palate required. Anyone can buy a ticket.

Historical fiction certainly offers an abundance of facts and information.

Feature #6 – “All twelve of these bestsellers expose the inner workings of at least one secret society.”

Let’s have a look at Hall’s examples. The Godfather exposes the mafia. Jaws exposes the secrets of the sea. The Da Vince Code – Opus Dei. The Bridges of Madison County – the secret world of adultery. To Kill a Mockingbird – the KKK.

And here’s the punchline – our simple, everyday heroes triumph over these secret societies. Good over evil.

Question: in historical fiction do we see monarchies and the nobility as secret societies?

The final six features will be posted on Monday.

Insights from Hit Lit .. and author James W. Hall

06 Thursday Sep 2012

Posted by awriterofhistory in Historical Fiction

≈ 11 Comments

Tags

best sellers, Hit Lit, ingredients for best sellers, James W. Hall, Michael Korda

What writer could resist the title: Hit Lit: Cracking the Code of the Twentieth Century’s Biggest Bestsellers?

Having just finished this book, I’d like to share a few notable insights. Bear with me as this will likely require more than one post.

Here’s the first quote, one that James Hall includes from another author, Michael Korda who has written about American bestsellers.

 

At least half the books on any given week’s bestseller list are there to the immense surprise and puzzlement of their publishers … That’s why publishers find it so hard to repeat their successes – half the time they can’t figure out how they happened in the first place.

Aha … perhaps this is why my agent and I are having trouble finding a publisher for my novels!

Hall organizes his book to reveal twelve features of hit lit. The first feature is “An Offer You Can’t Refuse” – essentially tricks of the trade that make a story so compelling the reader can’t put it down. What are these tricks?

A novel must:

  • entertain
  • engage readers in a compelling, simple and dramatic premise
  • offer an unfolding story with “one complication after another”
  • include characters “of deep conviction and fervent, stubborn resolve, capable of passions that rise well beyond the normal range of human experience”
  • make the story worth the readers’ time by forging a “powerful emotional bond … composed of one part pity, one part fear”
  • minimize backstory
  • create “some form of serious peril” very early on
  • enhance the tension with “the power of the ticking clock”

Feedback: what historical fiction authors or novels do you think follow these tricks of the trade?

Next post … a few more of the twelve features.

← Older posts

Recent Posts

  • The blurring of truth and fiction
  • An Interview with Historical Fiction Author – Helen Bryan
  • Edward IV’s Women by Anne Easter Smith
  • Favourite historical fiction author – Edward Rutherfurd
  • Writing a book blurb

Archives

Enter your email address to follow this blog and receive notifications of new posts by email.

BLOG CATEGORIES

Author Entrepreneur Book Club Gals Connecting Readers & Writers Family History Guest Posts Historical Fiction Historical Fiction Blogs Historical Fiction Enthusiasts Historical Fiction Survey Historical Non-Fiction Industry News Military Stories Researching historical fiction Top Historical Fiction Authors Top Historical Fiction Sites Uncategorized Writing about WWI Writing about WWII Writing Process

CONNECT ON FACEBOOK

CURRENTLY READING

No data found
Book recommendations, book reviews, quotes, book clubs, book trivia, book lists

Blog at WordPress.com. Theme: Chateau by Ignacio Ricci.